Greg Palast, in an interview published at Alternative News, mentions the GOPs use of caging lists. As you'll see, this is something else I've done a little reading into…
GREG PALAST: And '08, so what's happening is there is no fix of the system. In other words, just like black folk get bad schools and bad hospitals, they get the bad voting machines, which are going to kill those votes. But they're not satisfied with just letting the ballots be thrown away. They're going to move it along. And one of the things I discovered is the Republican Party has something called "caging lists," which came to our — you know, just like you had Friday, the way the Yes Men capture material by using false websites, so through a false website we were able to capture Republican Party internal missives, through georgebush.org.And so, what happened was is that they sent us a bunch of lists of literally tens of thousands of names of voters and addresses. We were wondering what the heck this was. It turns out these were almost all African American voters, who they were prepared to challenge in 2004, and they did, to say that these people shouldn't vote, because their addresses are suspect. And you'll see in the book that in the lists of thousands of black voters that they were challenging over their address were thousands of black soldiers who were sent to Iraq; go to Baghdad, and the Republican Party challenges your vote.
So, how what happened with this one?
It all started with a post in the days prior to the 2004 Election. I posted to the blog about some emails that were sent to georgewbush.org:
So apparently Cheney isn’t alone in his *.com / *.org / *.net confusion. GeorgeWBush.org (cache), a satire site, has a “catch-all” on their mailserver that collects any emails addressed to anyone@georgebush.org. Fortunately, no one configured the mailserver to ignore such emails.The full emails, including attachments, are included in the link. Apparently, Greg Palast, of the BBC, had an article sourced from those emails, detailing a plan by Bush staffers to challenge voters in Florida that they felt were not legally allowed to vote, which they refer to as a “caging list.”
Two e-mails, prepared for the executive director of the Bush campaign in Florida
and the campaign’s national research director in Washington DC, contain a
15-page so-called “caging list”. It lists 1,886 names and addresses of voters in
predominantly black and traditionally Democrat areas of Jacksonville, Florida.
…”The only possible reason why they would keep such a thing is to challenge
voters on election day.”Of course the Republicans deny this…
For reference sake, here's the original caging list email:
Received: from 208.241.56.10 ([208.241.56.10]) for [bdoster@georgewbush.org] with MailEnable Catch-All Filter; Thu, 26 Aug 2004 18:34:10 -0400
Received: from rnc1.rnchq.org ([208.241.56.10]) by chickenhead.com with MailEnable ESMTP; Thu, 26 Aug 2004 18:34:10 -0400
X-MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft Exchange V6.0.6249.0
content-class: urn:content-classes:message
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain;
charset=”us-ascii”
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
Subject: Re: caging
Date: Thu, 26 Aug 2004 18:34:06 -0400
Message-ID: [3E012FD97229764ABC365
703617F542001C536E9@rnc1.rnchq.org]
X-MS-Has-Attach:
X-MS-TNEF-Correlator:
Thread-Topic: caging
Thread-Index: AcSLt/eE7gJz86stSe2OcTDaw1xKDAABNQbb
From: “Tim Griffin – Research/Communications” [tgriffin@rnchq.org]
To: [kporter@rpof.org],
“Lindy Landreaux – Political” [LLandreaux@rnchq.org],
“Miriam Moore – Research/Communications” [MMoore@rnchq.org],
“Victoria Newton – Research/Communications” [VNewton@rnchq.org],
“Shawn Reinschmiedt – Research/Communications”
[SReinschmiedt@rnchq.org],
[rkammerdiner@rnchq.org],
[sshiver@rpof.org],
[bdoster@georgewbush.org]
X-Read: 1—–Original Message—–
From: Tim Griffin – Research/Communications [mailto:tgriffin@rnchq.org]
Sent: Thursday, August 26, 2004 6:34 PM
To: kporter@rpof.org; Lindy Landreaux – Political [mailto:LLandreaux@rnchq.org]; Miriam Moore – Research/Communications [mailto:MMoore@rnchq.org]; Victoria Newton – Research/Communications [mailto:VNewton@rnchq.org]; Shawn Reinschmiedt – Research/Communications [SReinschmiedt@rnchq.org]; rkammerdiner@rnchq.org; sshiver@rpof.org; bdoster@georgewbush.org
Subject: Re: cagingThx
Tim Griffin
Research Director and
Deputy Communications Director
Republican National Committee
310 First Street, S.E.
Washington, D.C. 20003
w:(202) 863-8815
f: (202) 863-8744
tgriffin@rnchq.org> —–Original Message—–
> From: Kelly Porter [kporter@rpof.org]
> To: Lindy Landreaux – Political [LLandreaux@rnchq.org]; Miriam Moore – Research/Communications [MMoore@rnchq.org]; Victoria Newton – Research/Communications [VNewton@rnchq.org]; Tim Griffin – Research/Communications [tgriffin@rnchq.org]; Shawn Reinschmiedt – Research/Communications [SReinschmiedt@rnchq.org]; rkammerdiner@rnchq.org [rkammerdiner@rnchq.org]; Stephen Shiver [sshiver@rpof.org]; bdoster@georgewbush.org [bdoster@georgewbush.org]
> Sent: Thu Aug 26 18:12:49 2004
> Subject: caging
>
> Total as of today is 1834.
>
> Kelly
>
> ATTACHMENT: Caging-1.xls
I pulled the list, looked at it and then wondered…
There is another part of the “Caging” thing that I don’t get – the majority of the references that I see online referring to caging refer to donations. Could these people be people who donated to GWB? People who were in a mailing for GWB who’s mailings were return-to-sender?What do these people have in common besides race (possibly) and geography? Has anybody online contacted these people yet? What is the Jacksonville Press making out of it?
After more reading and digging, especially into the term "caging", I claimed that it wasn't a conspiracy:
I’m of the opinion that the caging list is not a Republican conspiracy to disenfranchise the African American voters. As has been posted many places around the web, including the Freepers state that a Caging List is a Mass Mailing term that refers to letters that are returned as undeliverable (to be caged – or removed from the active database).
Via the Direct Mail Glossary:
Caging
The process of receiving, processing, and reporting the mailing results
The Goodwill HUD Options Program
I M Sulzbacher Ctr for the Homeless
611 East Adams StJacksonville, FL 32202
General Info(904) 359-0457Mental Health Resource Center
305 N. Washington St.Jacksonville, FL 32202
(904).358.2411The CITY RESCUE MISSION
234 State ST W
Jacksonville, FL 32202
(904) 387-4357
The GeorgeWBush.org emails are REAL!!!!
Go to the dead letter office. http://www.georgewbush.org/deadletteroffice/
Read this about the file properties of one of the Excel attachments…http://riffle.blogspot.com/2004/10/caging.html
Check out this record from my server log… Guess somebody wanted to see how popular they were!
Note: Jeb Bush was just on NBC News saying that the Democrats have tons of lawyers to litigate every problem. Looks like they are trying to be prepared too.
In trying to figure out their rationale, I stumbled across this related story from Ohio:
Related story from WCLT, a radio station in Ohio.
Here’s the gist…a Republican challenger, Barbara Miller, presented a challenge to the eligibility of voters. The judge wisely threw out the challenges. Here’s where the list came from and how they got it.
In testimony to the Summit County Election Board, Miller said that her challenges were based on a list of "undeliverable mail" given to her by the Republican Party. The list was based on a GOP mailing sent to registered voters throughout the state of Ohio.
After Miller presented this as her evidence, Russell Pry, Summit County Election Board member, told her that she could be indicted for signing a sworn challenge without any personal knowledge about the eligibility of the voters. Miller's reaction was to plead the Fifth Amendment.Now, the next question is, where did these votes come from?
And the visits kept coming:
So far three people who are listed as being included as cc’ed on the Caging List emails mistakenly sent to georgewbush.org have Googled themselves and ended up at my website. One was the author of the caging list file, and an employee of the RPOF, one was involved in the legal proceedings the RNC filed in New Jersey regarding the voter challenges, and lastly was someone who’s day job includes working for the Family Resource Center.
What could they be looking at, this far after the election, after their guy won? One specifically included “caging” in her search string, so it wasn’t just trying to gauge her popularity?
So in conclusion, here was my deduction:
Apparently, the someone has been collecting registrations and sending out registered mail pieces to the addresses. If no one picks up the pieces, then those registrations will be challenged by a certain political party as fraudulent. This same party either barely won or barely lost the states in which this is occurring. So far, it is Nevada, Ohio, and of course, Florida.
Keep this in mind, as 2006 will be the test run for 2008.